Saturday 25 May 2013

The Shield - S1E2 "Our Gang"

Review


Ah, The Shield. I was always under the impression that this series starts slow. I was wrong.

This episode follows David's search for answers as Terry dies in the hospital from a gunshot wound inflicted by Vince. The subplot is about a churro vendor who was shot by a Los Magnificos gang member, and the sub-subplot is about the initiation of a rookie into the police force.

I like the way the show is developing its characters and the way the writers were able to use the rookie cop's interactions with Danni in this episode to paint a picture of what it's like to be a cop in this police force.

First, there's the news about Terry's fatal gunshot wound. Here, Danni scolds the rookie for not coming to the hospital after she left a message for him on his answering machine the other night:

"What?" he says. "I've been on the job three weeks. I didn't even know that guy"
She replies "Rule number one. He was a cop. You're a cop. You knew him."

Right away we get a feel for the sense of camaraderie these people have. And it speaks to her character, as well, that she's able to respect the situation and treat a death in the unit with due solemnity.

Another scene with similar effect sees the strike force teasing the rookie about needing to get initiated. Walking away from the group, he tells Danni he doesn't want to partake. Her response is that those men may just be over-grown frat guys, but one day they could be all that is standing between him and a bullet.

And it's true. Their jobs are often hard. In the worst of times they're life-or-death. And in those crucial moments all they have is each other. That's not a lesson you want to learn the hard way.

Yet - and I want to stress this as much as I can - they're still normal people. They have lives outside of work. They have relationships; families. They do things that normal people do. In the previous episode it was revealed that Mackie occasionally sleeps with Danni. This episode, we see Mackie at home and interacting with his wife and daughter.

It's also Claudette's birthday. She's older and she's being teased about it. Someone anonymous gets her a gift: dental paste. She goes to celebrate with her friend and a potential love interest after work. Earlier, she harshly criticizes the rookie cop about his handling of a crime scene. Her partner tells the rookie, with a smile, "don't take it too hard. She's in a pissy mood because it's her birthday"

I love that this show is able to be serious when the story needs it to be and light and humorous when it doesn't. One of my major criticisms of modern drama is that hardly anyone is ever having fun. Not so, here.

I'm very interested to see what comes of the David vs. Mackie storyline. Will Mackie get caught? How is Mackie affected by what he did? Will there need to be more casualties as others get closer to the truth? Is Shane liable to break if David keeps pressing? Until episode 3...

7/10

Odds and Ends


  • Why do cops always sit at the bar?
  • Walton Goggins is a seriously great actor. The interrogation by David is the best scene here.
  • I like the action shots in this series. Very active shaky-cam. They haven't overdone it yet.
  • Does Mackie's wife have a JOIIIISEY accent? (Jersey)
  • Liked this exchange:
    • Claudette: "We're too old to be chasing men around." 
    • Friend: "I'm not." 
    • Claudette: "Neither am I." 
  • I initially had issues with Mackie acting so shaken up after Terry died. Maybe this says more about how other shows and movies have conditioned me to see cops on the small screen. These guys do show emotion. Losing one of your own can't be an easy thing. Still, nice affectation there, Mackie! PUNK!
  • Terry's story about oral sex at the poker game reminded me of the bullshit story in Reservoir Dogs that the undercover cop has to sell the rest of the criminals on.


Maron S1E04 - Dominatrix

Review

This is my first review of the show Maron. I'm a big fan of Marc Maron's podcast "WTF With Marc Maron" and I want to like this show and wish him all the best, but I don't think this series will last very long.

In this particular episode, Maron gets the news that his ex-wife is doing well and has a child. When he doesn't take the news as well as he could, a friend of his tells him he needs to move on and says she knows someone that she could set him up with. The girl in question is a bookstore owner named Megan and is a good ten years younger than Maron. They meet at a live reading at her shop and he hits it off with her rather well, but he's more drawn to another woman at the reading - a dominatrix. And thus begins the story.

The dominatrix's name is Justine and she's not particularly well written. This is a woman who is likely in her early 40's yet she tries to convince Maron to get kinky with her even when he has indicated that he's not comfortable with it. She calls him a coward and later goes as far as to lie in order to get him to show up to her day job while she's actively dominating a client. Then, once Maron has broken up with her, she sleeps with his dad to get back at him. Ugh. These aren't the actions of a forty-something adult.

What's more problematic is that Marc breaks up with her because she bakes him banana bread. To him, this spells commitment and he's not at all down with that. This would be fine, were it not for the fact that the episode didn't play out the way it did. This wasn't "Marc is afraid of commitment". This was "Marc is nervous about getting freaky with this cartoony dominatrix who publicly talks about putting her foot up a client's ass".

The commitment issues came out of left field and the break-up moment felt cheap even though it was played for laughs. Maron does eventually sleep with the nice girl. He also tells her he's bad for her. It's too bad that the show had to explore Maron's love-life in such a clunky way. An unsatisfying end to a very unsatisfying episode.

2/10

Odds and Ends


  • Love the Maron theme song, or at least I think I do. It's a song by Reel Big Fish called "Sell Out"
  • Is "The Jerusalem Syndrome" actually a book written by Marc? Now I'm curious...
  • I'm surprised Marc is a recovering addict. I didn't know that about him.
  • This episode made Marc really hard to like. I felt sorry for Megan throughout. She seemed so sweet.
  • I liked Marc's acting when he and Justine were in bed and he awkwardly talked to her about being able to do the BDSM thing but not wanting to. I wonder if the episode would have worked better without this scene, though. It tricked me into thinking I was watching an episode about Marc's weird sex adventures. I shuddered at the thought of that. Maybe I would have preferred it.
  • I really liked the previous episode. Don't watch this one. Watch that one.